Pies & Desserts
Double Crust Pies
Tart granny smith apples, delicately flavored with our own special blend of spices.
A famous recipe of sun-ripened apricots, flavored to perfection and bursting with golden goodness. Available for pre-0rder only. Not available by the slice.
Mounds of wild mountain and cultivated blueberries for old time flavor. Available for pre-0rder only. Not available by the slice.
Luscious boysenberries, chock full of tangy flavor. All berries are USDA Grade "A". All the berries in this pie are real boysenberries.
“Old-World” Cherry“Old-World” Cherry image
Red, tart and juicy cherries captured in one of Polly's original pies.
Old fashion country-kitchen flavor enhanced with a touch of cinnamon.
Only the finest Northwestern rhubarb with a tangy sweet-sour taste. Available for pre-0rder only. Not available by the slice.
Cream Pies & Custards
Banana CreamBanana Cream image
Plump fresh bananas lavished in creamy vanilla custard and topped with whipped cream.
Polly’s Own Banberry®Polly’s Own Banberry® image
Ms. Polly's delicious banana cream filling, topped with fresh sweet strawberries and a ring of real whipped cream.
Coconut CreamCoconut Cream image
The finest shredded Hawaiian Coconut is drenched in rich old-fashioned custard topped with whipped cream.
Chocolate CreamChocolate Cream image
Deep rich chocolate, made from egg custard and cocoa, topped with whipped cream.
Sunnylicious Lemon Cream CheeseSunnylicious Lemon Cream Cheese image
Vanilla cream cheese base with tasty lemon filling, topped with a ring of real whipped cream, and garnished with fresh sliced lemon.
Lemon MeringueLemon Meringue image
Lots of tasty lemon filling with a mountain of toasted meringue.
An old-fashioned egg custard, rich and creamy, spiced just right.
A special velvety blend of pumpkin, eggs, cinnamon and ginger cooked the old fashioned way.
No Sugar Added Pies
*Subject to availability
Specialty Pies and Desserts
Apple CrispApple Crisp image
Tart granny smith apples, delicately flavored with our own special blend of spices, covered with a sweet crumbly topping.
Chocolate SilkChocolate Silk image
Silky chocolate baked in our famous pie crust and topped with real whipped cream.
Southern Style PecanSouthern Style Pecan image
Real southern style pecan pie, loaded with pecans and flooded with caramel-flavored filling.
Fruit Topped CheesecakeFruit Topped Cheesecake image
Seasonal Fresh Fruit
Fresh strawberries tossed in strawberry glaze atop our famous pie crust.
Fresh peaches tossed in a sweet peach glaze atop our famous pie crust.
Fresh olallieberries tossed in a sweet glaze atop our famous pie crust.
Upgrade any slice of pie to a Pie Shake for $1.99! Plus cost of slice of pie. Try one of our favorites: Banberry, Boysenberry, or Pumpkin!
Banberry Pie Shake
A slice of Banberry pie blended into a delicious shake!
Boysenberry Pie ShakeBoysenberry Pie Shake image
A slice of freshly baked Boysenberry Pie blended into a delicious shake!
Pumpkin Pie ShakePumpkin Pie Shake image
A slice of freshly baked Pumpkin Pie blended into a delicious shake!